Central Valley Ecological Benefits Assessment

Central Valley, CA
This analysis was designed to assist in state-level decision-making for critical habitat restoration projects.

The multi-part model integrates core principles of landscape ecology to quantify the benefits of habitat restoration to species and ecosystems.

Terrestrial Species Model Inputs

Terrestrial Species Model Outputs

Salmonid Run Accumulation Model

The flood system in California’s Central Valley is among the largest human landscape interventions in the world. It’s comprised of 1,500 miles of levees and 200,000 acres of floodways which intersect 18,000 parcel easements. There are one million people living within the floodplain along side approximately $70 billion in assets, yet more than half of the levees and floodways do not meet their design criteria or are at a high risk of failure. Proper management of this flood infrastructure is critical to the protection of these communities and assets. The state of California Department of Water Resources (DWR) utilizes an integrated solutions approach to flood management which considers a highly diverse range of criteria to ensure that both the performance of the system and the needs of the stakeholders are successfully met.

Ecologically, the Central Valley has been dramatically transformed by this infrastructure; the floodplains have been largely disconnected from the rivers, 95% of historical wetland and riparian vegetation no longer exists, 90% of salmonid rearing habitat has disappeared and there are now 25 associated threatened and endangered species that rely on this shrinking habitat. Therefore, an important part of DWR’s integrated solutions approach is the restoration of native riparian habitats to support target species and promote ecological function.

Knot principal Michael Yun co-led the development of a custom ecological model which helped DWR evaluate numerous options for potential restoration actions throughout the Central Valley and assist State Level decision-making for project implementation. The team faced a unique challenge when trying to quantify the ecological benefits for these wide-ranging projects; how would similar actions in geographically disparate locations differentially benefit target species identified in the state’s conservation strategy?

Quantifying ecological benefits may be required to secure federal funding for restoration projects within the flood system and the existing USACE federally-certified models have generally been developed to evaluate specific sites, geographies or species and weren’t suited for the geographic scale and species diversity encountered in this assessment. In order to resolve this critical issue, Knot developed a two-part model which integrated core principles of landscape ecology to quantify the differential benefits to species partially based on project location. This resulted in sensitive quantified outputs that reflected proximity of proposed habitat to key population sources of target species.

In order to achieve this outcome, Knot evaluated habitat and population connectivity through the application of both least cost path and Circuitscape assessments which were combined using an index of connectivity equation which was developed for this project. The resulting index of connectivity score was then used to value weight a habitat acre quality score and summed per action per site. The final result represents a value weighted acre which was influenced by proposed habitat type, habitat quantity and habitat connectivity to target species.

Knot evaluated habitat connectivity with a new model that combined least cost path and Circuitscape outputs into an Index of Connectivity.

California Department of Water Resources
California Central Valley
CH2M Hill, H.T. Harvey & Associates Ecological Consultants
The model was used to evaluate benefits for 17 target species spread over a dozen restoration sites across the San Joaquin and Sacramento River basins.